Tilman married Martha Causby Plumley about 1870. Martha (daughter of Mathias Plumley and Mary Smith) was born on 28 Aug 1852 in Big Laurel Creek, Boone Co, WV; died on 1 Jun 1925 in Branchland, Lincoln Co, WV; was buried in Keck Cemetery, Branchland, Lincoln Co, WV. [Group Sheet]